< home # store # services # articles # game # app #contact >

In the western hemisphere, Tibitó in Colombia and Taima Taima in Venezuela are two archaeological sites in South America. They have sparked debate about the timing and nature of early humans. Both are believed to contain evidence of human activity dating back to the pre-Clovis period. Suggesting that humans may have been present in South America earlier than widely accepted timelines.

Tibitó is an archaeological site in Colombia that some researchers argue contains signs of early human presence, including stone tools that may date back 14,000-15,000 years
However, the findings are still considered controversial due to challenges in definitively linking artifacts to human activity. Critics argue that some of the stone artifacts could have been created by natural processes rather than human hands. The lack of clear association with other artifacts or fossils has left the site questionable.

Taima-Taima is a Late Pleistocene archaeological site located about 20 kilometers east of Santa Ana de Coro, in the Falcón State of Venezuela
In the northwest region of Venezuela, Taima Taima is one of south America’s most famous potential Pre-Clovis sites. The site has yielded a variety of artifacts, including stone tools and a carved bone point embedded in a notiomastodon pelvic bone. It is interpreted as evidence of human hunting. Some estimates date the human activity at this site to more than 13,000 years ago.

Natural disturbances controversy
The main point of contention with Taima Taima is the stratigraphy (the layering of soil and deposits) and whether the artifacts are definitively associated with the bones and dated layers. Critics argue that the artifacts could have migrated to older layers due to natural disturbances. Which could provide a misleading impression of their age. Additionally, some scholars believe that the evidence is not conclusive enough to prove human presence that far back in time.

El Jobo projectile
Scientists discovered the El Jobo projectile points, which are believed to be the earliest such artefacts in South America, going back to 16,000 years ago. This was a major discovery in Paleoindian archaeology points, which are believed to be the earliest such artefacts in South America.

There were also signs of Xenorhinotherium, an extinct animal similar to camels but with a nose like a moose

The significance of Tibitó and Taima Taima lies in their potential to challenge the idea that humans arrived in South America only after crossing north America. If these sites do represent early human occupation, they could support alternative migration theories, such as coastal migration route or even crossing the ocean. Despite the controversies, these sites have fueled ongoing research into the complexity of human migration into the Americas. They suggest humans settled earlier, more diverse and widespread than previously thought.

Bibliography:

José R. Oliver, Implications of Taima-taima and the Peopling of Northern South America. (http://www.bradshawfoundation.com/journey/taima-taima-text.html) bradshawfoundation.com

Ochsenius, C. and R. Gruhn, eds. (1979) Taima-taima. A Late Paleo-Indian Kill Site in Northernmost South America. Final Reports of the 1976 Excavations. CIPICS/South American Quaternary Documentation Program. Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany (includes chapters by J. M. Cruxent, A. L. Bryan, R. Gruhn, R. M. Casimiquiela and C. Ochsenius)

Oliver, J.R., Alexander, C.S. (2003). Ocupaciones humanas del Plesitoceno terminal en el Occidente de Venezuela. Maguare, 17 83-246

Silverman, Helaine; Isbell, William (2008). Handbook of South American Archaeology (https://books.google.com/books?id=yZr-lxQgJiAC&pg=PA433). Springer Science. p. 433. ISBN 978-0-387-75228-0.